The U.S. Government’s Secret Cheese Caves: Why America Is Hoarding 1.4 Billion Pounds of Dairy
Deep beneath Springfield, Missouri, there’s a refrigerated world most Americans have never seen. It’s dark, quiet, and lined with limestone walls that stretch for miles. Inside, under the steady hum of industrial chillers, sit massive blocks of cheese stacked like gold bars in a vault. This is not an urban legend or the plot of a food-themed heist movie.
The United States is sitting on more than a billion pounds of cheese, quietly stored away in underground bunkers. How this mountain of dairy came to exist says a lot about American farming, politics, and our complicated love affair with food subsidies.
The Birth Of A Dairy Dilemma
Image via Wikimedia Commons/Unknown
The roots of America’s cheese surplus stretch back to the Great Depression. When milk prices collapsed in the 1930s, dairy farmers faced ruin. Desperate to stabilize the market, President Franklin D. Roosevelt created the Commodity Credit Corporation, a government program designed to buy surplus crops and livestock products. This was meant to help farmers stay afloat while preventing food prices from crashing.
In the 1940s, the idea of stockpiling agricultural goods had become official policy, and cheese quickly became one of the easiest products to hoard. The federal government kept supporting the dairy industry through wars, recessions, and changing diets. During World War II, milk and cheese were considered essential to feeding soldiers, and dairy became a symbol of national strength.
When refrigerators made fresh milk easier to store, Americans started drinking more of it. Later in the 1940s, cheese production was booming, and Washington promised to buy up any excess. The system worked, perhaps a little too well.
When Jimmy Carter Flooded The Market
Image via iStockphoto/anatoliycherkas
During the 1970s, inflation surged and farmers across the country struggled to stay afloat. President Jimmy Carter responded with a $2 billion aid package for the dairy industry, designed to stabilize food prices and keep farms alive. The plan worked in one sense. It protected farmers from collapse, but it also unleashed an avalanche of milk. To prevent spoilage, the surplus was turned into cheese, butter, and powdered milk until the government was swimming in dairy products.
By 1980, warehouses overflowed with cheese—an estimated 500 million pounds waiting for a use. The overflow grew so large that old limestone mines in Missouri were transformed into massive refrigerated bunkers. Kept at ≈ 58 °F adjustable storage, the underground environment was perfect for long-term preservation. It was efficient, yes, but also a little absurd. The government had effectively created secret cheese caves beneath the heart of America.
The Era Of Government Cheese
When Ronald Reagan entered office in 1981, the nation’s dairy vaults had reached comical proportions. Reporters began questioning why the government was sitting on mountains of dairy while Americans lined up at food banks. During a press event, Agriculture Secretary John R. Block lifted a five-pound block of processed cheese and confessed, “We’ve got 60 million of these that the government owns.” His fix was simple: distribute it to the public.
What followed became a cultural phenomenon known as government cheese. Millions of pounds were handed out through food banks, welfare programs, and school lunches. The cheese was dense, salty, and packed in cardboard boxes stamped “U.S. Department of Agriculture.”
For struggling families, it was a lifeline during tough economic times. For critics, it symbolized waste and mismanagement. Either way, it left an impression. At one point in the mid-1980s, there was enough cheese in government storage to equal about five pounds for every American.
From Cheese Caves To Pizza Chains
Image via Wikimedia Commons/Rosenthal, James W.
After the stockpiling era ended, Washington didn’t exactly walk away from dairy. Instead of physically storing cheese, federal agencies began funding marketing campaigns and partnerships with major food companies. The famous “Got Milk?” ads of the 1990s were launched with government-backed dairy boards, while behind the scenes, the USDA worked with chains like Domino’s and Taco Bell to create cheese-heavy menus. In one deal, the USDA funded a $12 million campaign to promote Domino’s pizzas featuring 40% more cheese.
The strategy worked. As Americans moved away from drinking milk, they started eating more of it. By the 2000s, cheese was everywhere—from school cafeterias to fast-food menus—and consumption had tripled compared to the 1970s.
A Billion Pounds And Counting
Even with all the cheese devoured on burgers, tacos, and pizzas, production still outpaces demand. The Department of Agriculture’s 2024 Cold Storage Report showed nearly 1.4 billion pounds of cheese sitting in commercial inventory across the country. These supplies belong to private companies rather than the federal government and are spread through refrigerated warehouses nationwide. Some of that stock still sits below Missouri, stored in the same limestone chambers now run by Springfield Underground, which leases space to food giants like Kraft Heinz and Nestlé.
The federal government may no longer own most of the cheese, but its fingerprints remain on the system. Dairy subsidies still flow through the budget, and every federally funded school lunch must include milk. Even as more Americans cut dairy or switch to plant-based alternatives, the connection between agriculture policy and the dairy industry remains tightly woven.
Every so often, the story resurfaces online, leaving people amazed that the country still holds a billion-pound mountain of cheese underground. Yet it’s real. As long as farms keep producing more milk than Americans can drink, those subterranean vaults will stay stocked.